But what this film really needed was an editor The climax of the film is the attack on Pearl Harbor - an American defeat.I remember a story on a national morning TV news program that was a major promotion for the debut of this huge waste of celluloid.This interviewpromotion took place aboard the aircraft carrier thats on permanent display in New York harbor.The major male stars, Ben Affleck and Josh Hartnett, along with Producer Jerry Bruckheimer were interviewed by one of the hosts of this TV morning news show.
In this interview, all three claimed that they enjoyed talking to veterans and listening to their stories. ![]() Or at least they decided to ignore reality when it interfered with their script Some historical facts that got in the way of Bruckheimers blockbuster: It doesnt matter how simple WWII aircraft are compared to todays jets. Ask any pilot and heshe can tell you that you just dont go from flying American P-40 fighters one day, go to England and jump into the cockpit of a British Spitfire fighter and start shooting down HIGHLY EXPERIENCED, COMBAT VETERAN German PILOTS the next (I dont care that even a blind pig can find the occasional acorn) Each aircrafts handling qualities, e.g., speed, max altitude, rate of climb, rate of dive, turning, etc., are different. In other words, a pilot has to be TRAINED on that aircraft To ask us to believe that Afflecks character, who hadnt seen REAL aerial combat prior to England, can shoot down experienced German fighter pilots the VERY FIRST TIME HE STRAPS ON A SPIT is not only LAUGHABLE, its insulting to the REAL pilots who fought and died in the Battle of Britain. The famous Doolittle Raid took place on April 18, 1942 - a scant 4-12 months after the Pearl Harbor attack. Yet, were supposed to believe that not only can Afflecks character IMMEDIATELY master unfamiliar aircraft (forgetting that a B-25 is a MULTI-ENGINE BOMBER no less for the moment), apparently so can Josh Hartnetts character. It took EXPERIENCED B-25 bomber crews about that long to train for this extremely hazardous raid on Japan (January 1942 to April 18, 1942). No way in the world could P-40 fighter pilots be chosen to fly B-25 bombers in the Doolittle Raid What I dont understand is that since Bruckheimer was obviously not interested in historical accuracy, in addition to Afflecks characters superhuman abilities of shooting down EXPERIENCED Germans pilots over England and BATTLE TESTED Japanese pilots over Pearl Harbor, rescuing sailors trapped in half-sunk ships, giving blood, and eventually taking the war to the Japanese in the Doolittle Raid, why didnt Bruckheimer just have Afflecks character pump-out and raise the Arizona and single-handedly save her crew from their watery grave. Thank goodness there are some things even Bruckheimer cant swallow The special effects and battle scenes were great Yeah, I know. Subtitle Bahasa Indonesia Pearl Harbour Movie Is BasedBUT, if you want an entertaining, more historically accurate dramatic portrayal of the events of, and leading up to, December 7th, 1941, stick with Tora Tora Tora That movie is based upon the work of a historian considered by many to be the top of his field, Gordon Prange. Although Dr. Prange wrote many books on this topic, I believe his book, At Dawn We Slept was the basis of Tora Tora Tora As a MEDAL OF HONOR winner, General Doolittle, and the heroic pilots he led on that raid deserved better than the way they were portrayed in Bruckheimers schlock film. Despite the romance scenes, and when it was filmed, 30 Seconds Over Tokyo is a much more accurate depiction of the famous Doolittle Raid. At least its more believable Affleck, Hartnett, and Bruckheimer may have listened to WWII veterans, but they did not hear. They did not learn. Nor did they appreciate the immeasurable costs paid by those members of this countrys greatest generation. The only things I recognized as historically accurate about this film were: 1) the US was attacked at Pearl Harbor by Japan on December 7th, 1941; 2) the US Army did fly P-40s; 3) British pilots did do combat with Germans in the skies over England during the Battle of Britain; 4) some British pilots did crash into the Channel; 5) Cuba Goodings character, a black mess cook, DID shoot down Japanese planes even though he received no gunnery training; and 6) Doolittle did lead a force of 16 US Army B-25 bombers from the carrier USS Hornet against Japan. I cant speak to any accuracies about the nurses, or their quick thinking, e.g., writing with lipstick on the foreheads of the wounded. The only way Id own a copy of this film is if someone accidentally gave it to me as a gift. It ranks up there with the opening sequence from Saving Private Ryan and the sinking of the Titanic as one of the most harrowing disaster sequences filmed in recent years. But like both those other two films, PEARL HARBOR is desperately in need of a decent script to frame the disaster sequence. Okay - I could almost accept the hokey old love triangle romantic plot - certainly the stars are great to look at - but the dialogue really sucked: I dont think Ill ever look at another sunset without thinking of you. Please And all those hero shots from the ground, and the slow motion love bits, and the soppy music, and the eternal sunsets.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |